Tucows is probably the most well known shareware site listed on their awards page. It gives only 3 out of 5 stars as the rating.
http://www.tucows.com/preview/334433
http://www.sparkleware.com/superbot/awards.html
In addition, this software has not been reviewed by major industry press.
If this status changes SuperBot may be promoted to the high profile list.
Nonetheless, this is a border-line case. If anyone provides good reasons for moving it back to the high profile list then it should be provided here. However, the text above should also be preserved for historical purposes.